Apple's new $599 iPhone 17E presents itself as an appealing entry-level iOS device, especially for those seeking a budget-friendly phone that still offers many premium features found in Apple's flagship models. The phone has been praised for its solid build quality, a higher base storage of 256GB, and the inclusion of MagSafe wireless charging. However, while these features make the iPhone 17E an attractive option, a closer look at other iPhone models in a similar price range suggests that there might be better choices available for consumers.
The launch of the iPhone 17E coincided with the release of the $599 MacBook Neo, giving an interesting perspective on how Apple is rolling out value-oriented options in different product categories. The MacBook Neo is widely regarded as an excellent laptop for its price, effectively replacing older discounted MacBook Air models and becoming Apple's most affordable laptop. This new MacBook offers a compelling reason to buy a brand-new device rather than an older model. However, the same comparison does not necessarily hold true for the iPhone 17E in the smartphone lineup.
There are several reasons why a shopper might consider older iPhone models instead of the brand-new iPhone 17E. For example, brand-new iPhone 15 models can be purchased for as low as $530, and they offer more advanced camera features than the iPhone 17E. Both the iPhone 15 and iPhone 16 share many features with the 17E but also include enhancements that may appeal to buyers. Notably, both the iPhone 15 and 16 have a 48-megapixel wide-angle camera comparable to the iPhone 17E's single rear camera, but they also feature a 12-megapixel ultrawide camera. This additional lens allows users to capture photos and videos with a wider field of view at 0.5x magnification-a capability the iPhone 17E lacks.
Moreover, these older flagship models are still available brand new and priced competitively. At the time of writing, the iPhone 15 costs around $530, and the iPhone 16 is priced at about $630 when purchased from Best Buy with activation on AT&T or Verizon networks. Buyers can also take advantage of Apple's Certified Refurbished program, which offers these phones at discounted prices with the assurance that Apple has replaced any necessary parts and guarantees the devices with a warranty.
For instance, a 128GB iPhone 15 refurbished by Apple is priced at $529, while the 256GB model, matching the iPhone 17E's storage, costs $619. Although this is $20 more than the iPhone 17E's $599 price, the dual-camera system and additional video features like Cinematic mode and Action mode-which are not available on the 17E-make the iPhone 15 a more versatile choice.
When it comes to newer features like Apple Intelligence and the programmable Action button, the iPhone 16 offers these, whereas the iPhone 15 does not. A refurbished iPhone 16 with 128GB of storage is available for about $619, supporting Apple Intelligence and including the Action button. However, upgrading to the 256GB storage variant raises the price to around $699, which is $100 more than the iPhone 17E. This option may appeal to those who want the latest software features and hardware enhancements but are willing to pay a premium for them.
For buyers comfortable with purchasing used phones from third-party sellers, the used market offers even more compelling options. The iPhone 15 Pro, for example, is frequently available in "Renewed" condition on platforms like Amazon, Gazelle, and BackMarket at attractive prices. This model significantly outperforms the iPhone 17E in terms of features, offering three rear cameras-including a 3x telephoto lens-and an A17 Pro processor capable of utilizing Apple Intelligence.
Currently, on Amazon, a 512GB iPhone 15 Pro in renewed condition sells for between $557 and $600, depending on the color. These phones typically have at least 80% of their original battery capacity, which Apple recommends as the threshold for considering a battery replacement. A Renewed Premium edition with a battery capacity closer to 90% costs about $620. While these used devices may show some visible wear, their functionality should remain unaffected.
Battery life is a critical factor when considering used devices. For example, a refurbished iPhone 13 Mini with battery capacity at 83% proved frustrating to use due to reduced battery longevity. Apple's official battery replacement cost is $99 for the iPhone 15 and 16 models, and $69 for the iPhone 13 Mini, but replacements are only officially done when capacity drops below 80%.
While third-party repair shops and DIY kits exist, these options either void the warranty or carry risk. Nevertheless, many used phones come with limited warranties and return windows, which can give buyers some peace of mind. For instance, the iPhone 13 Mini purchased used came with a 90-day return policy, allowing for testing of battery performance in real-world use.
Without this window, buyers might face the additional expense of a battery replacement after purchase.
In summary, the iPhone 17E offers a solid option for those seeking a new phone with the latest processor, sufficient storage, and convenient features like MagSafe. However, it is important for buyers to consider the broader market of iOS devices available in the $500 to $700 range. The older iPhone 15 and iPhone 16 provide enhanced camera capabilities and additional software features, often at comparable or slightly higher prices, especially when purchased through Apple's Certified Refurbished program. For those open to used devices, the iPhone 15 Pro presents an even more feature-rich alternative, with a powerful processor and versatile camera setup, though buyers should be mindful of battery health and potential wear.
With the retirement of the iPhone SE line, options for budget-friendly new iPhones have narrowed, making it all the more important to weigh these alternatives carefully. Whether opting for a brand-new iPhone 17E, a refurbished iPhone 15 or 16, or a renewed iPhone 15 Pro, consumers have choices that balance cost with features, performance, and longevity. Detailed comparisons of these models' specifications and prices can help shoppers decide the best fit for their needs and budget.